BREAKING! Saint Benitez Strikes Again: A Landmark Decision on California's Assault Weapons Ban
2A Cops is free, but if you want to support our work, please think about upgrading this subscription to “paid” so we can keep the lights on!
A Victory for the Second Amendment
In a landmark decision that has sent shockwaves through the legal community, Judge Roger T. Benitez of the United States District Court for the Southern District of California has ruled against California's assault weapons ban. Known affectionately by Second Amendment advocates as "Saint Benitez," the judge has once again championed the rights of gun owners. The decision, filed on October 19, 2023, is a significant win for proponents of the Second Amendment. Judge Benitez states, "Like the Bowie Knife which was commonly carried by citizens and soldiers in the 1800s, 'assault weapons' are dangerous, but useful" (Page 1).
The Crux of the Matter: The Constitutionality of the Ban
Judge Benitez's ruling delves deep into the constitutional implications of California's assault weapons ban. He argues that the United States Constitution "guarantee[s] the individual right to possess and carry weapons in case of confrontation" (Page 1). The judge also cites statistics to debunk the state's rationale behind the ban, stating, "In California, with a population close to 39 million people, murder by knife occurs seven times more often than murder by rifle" (Page 8). He further criticizes the state's approach, stating that it "promotes an important public interest of disarming some mass shooters even though it makes criminals of law-abiding residents who insist on acquiring these firearms for self-defense" (Page 8).
The judge questions the state's rationale for criminalizing the possession of certain rifles, stating that the ban has no historical pedigree and is extreme compared to laws in other states and at the federal level. He argues that the state's ban takes away the choice of using an AR-15 type rifle for self-defense, stating, "Americans have an individual right to keep and bear firearms" (Page 1).
The Immediate Impact: A Stayed Injunction
While the decision is a significant win for Second Amendment advocates, it's worth noting that the enforcement of the injunction against California's assault weapons law is stayed for ten days (Page 78). This means that the state has a brief window to appeal the decision before it takes effect. Nevertheless, the ruling has already ignited debates and discussions across the nation, and it will be interesting to see how this plays out in the coming days.
Judge Roger T. Benitez, or "Saint Benitez" as he is fondly called by many in the pro-Second Amendment community, has once again made a significant impact on gun rights in America. His well-reasoned decision against California's assault weapons ban is a strong affirmation of the Second Amendment and sets a precedent that could have far-reaching implications.